Cooking Dessert

Grandma’s Peanut Butter Fudge

Written by ASingleGirl

One of my favorite childhood memories is spending holidays at grandma’s house. My aunts and uncles would be there, so there was never a shortage of people to entertain me. My sister and I got to play in the backyard (croquet anyone?). And, of course, my favorite part of holidays at grandma’s house….her famous peanut butter fudge.

As a teenager I got her to teach me how to make it. But, like most grandmas, she didn’t have an exact recipe. She cooked by feel. And it turned out amazing every time.

Sadly my grandma is no longer with us. But holidays just aren’t the same without that childhood treat. So, this week I took my hand-written teenage-me notes from the original teaching session (I can’t believe I still have them after all these years!), and set out to recreate that nostalgic food memory. It took several attempts, but I finally got it right. And in one bite I was a little girl again.

Peanut butter fudge 01

Before you even turn on the stove, get everything prepared. You’ll be glad you did, because once you start to cook it goes fast and there’s no time to stop and gather an ingredient or prep a pan.

There are only three ingredients in Grandma’s Peanut Butter Fudge: sugar, milk, and peanut butter. Grandma’s ingredient list and amounts were not exact. They went something like this, “sugar, milk, and peanut butter with the sugar 2-1 over the milk and peanut butter.” Translation: for every one cup of peanut butter, you’ll need one cup of milk and two cups of sugar.

Peanut butter fudge 02

Grandma used to butter a regular dinner plate, then pour the fudge onto the plate, cool them, and serve them all on the same plate. With six kids and 2 grand-kids around the house, there was no need to worry about storing them – the fudge never lasted that long!

As a single girl, there’s no way I could eat an entire pan of fudge by myself. So, I prefer to make it in a square cake pan. Then I can slice the fudge into even squares, place them in little paper cups, and package them into pretty bags or boxes and give it to friends. I line the pan with foil, leaving some to overhang the edges so that I can easily lift the fudge out of the pan when it’s done cooling.

Peanut butter fudge 03

Put the sugar and milk into a high-sided sauce pan and bring to boil over a medium heat stirring constantly. Once you start cooking you CAN NOT walk away! Cooking with sugar can be dangerous, so you must babysit it constantly. Also, this mixture has a tendency to boil over. So, you want to make sure you’re stirring constantly so it doesn’t burn or boil over. And if it starts to boil over remove it from the flame for a second and reduce the heat slightly.

Grandma’s notes say to “cook to soft ball stage,” which means when you drop a small amount of the syrup into a bowl of cold water, you can scrape up the sugary mixture and make a soft ball with your fingers. Again – grandma cooked by feel. I’ve tried using this technique with only about 30% success rate. Most of the time I either overcook it (fudge is hard and crumbly) or under cook it (fudge never solidifies). So I decided to use a candy thermometer – and bingo! Success every time.

Boil the sugar/milk mixture until it reaches about 225-230 degrees. This is technically “thread” stage, and not quite soft ball, but I’ve found it works better and I never overcook it this way.

Peanut butter fudge 04

Once the sugar/milk mixture has reached the right temperature, remove it from the heat and add the peanut butter. Stir quickly until the peanut butter has melted and is completely combined. Depending on how hot/long you’ve cooked the sugar mixture you may have as little as a few seconds, or as much as a few minutes, to get it into the pan.

A note on peanut butter: This recipe has so much sugar that I’ve found the all-natural, no-sugar-added peanut butters work best.

Peanut butter fudge 05

Pour the hot peanut butter mixture into the prepared pan. If it’s liquid-y, it will even itself out. If it’s a bit more solid, you may have to use a spatula to spread it out in the pan.

Refrigerate, and when the fudge has mostly solidified but is still soft, slice into small squares. This fudge is very sweet and very rich, so small squares go a long way.

Peanut butter fudge 07

Now all that’s left is to enjoy this delicious treat with a cold glass of milk and a good chick flick.

Here’s the complete recipe. Enjoy!

2 cups sugar
1 cup milk
1 cup peanut butter (no-sugar-added varieties work best)

1) Pull all ingredients together and prepare square cake pan by lining with foil.
2) Combine sugar and milk in high-sided sauce pan.
3) Bring to boil and continue boiling until mixture reaches 225-230 degrees.
4) Remove from heat and add peanut butter. Stir quickly to combine.
5) Pour into prepared pan and spread into an even layer.
6) Refrigerate until firm.

Leave a Comment